Skip to main content

Reading Notes: Mahabharata, Kincaid Version, Part A

This week, I read an alternative version of the Mahabharata by C.A. Kincaid. This served as a more informative version of the story, for me personally.

To start, it really clarifies the lineage that the characters face. It sets up well the reasons that the two families dislike each other, but I thought that the best set up difference was when they compared how the five sons were all related to a different divine being. In addition, we get a better insight into how Krishna gets her name, and why she is thought of as so beautiful. One thing that causes issue (that did not before because I did not pick up on it) is that she marries five people at once. This is somewhat of an issue because in the Ramayana, Sita is banished to a test of fire and then to the forest over questions of her purity. But if all five are married (and it's not simultaneously, they clearly state it is one after the other), then why could people not believe that Sita marries Ravana, then Rama, and move on with life?

What is also more clear to me is the bow and arrow challenge. At first, it seemed to me that Arjuna was competing in the contest for land or for a title, but now that I have read this version, it is more clear that he is competing for Krishna. In addition, the author does a good job of setting up for the conflict that follows when Arjuna wins, as earlier, I thought that people were just annoyed for no reason that an outsider that they did not know had won.

Overall, this version of the story is a lot better for me, but I wonder if that is because I have already been exposed to the Mahabharata. I felt the same way about the second Ramayana story that we read,  but I believe it is because I had already seen and read the story to some capacity. One thing that this story does a lot better is how it flows and how it depicts the characters. The first section of the Mahabharata that we read was twenty smaller stories, and this one is only seven. That made the stories seem like less of an island on their own. This was personally an issue for me, because I did not know when a new story began.

In conclusion, it was a great version of the story to read, and I look forward to reading more.


Arjuna and Krishna first meet. Arjuna is the son of Indra, the the character of my project. Source: Wikimedia Commons


Bibliography
Mahabharata from The Indian Heroes by C.A. Kincaid

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Wikipedia Trail: From Indra to Pressure

This week, I researched more into Indra, the Thunder God, and followed a Wikipedia Trail that lead me to scientific pressure. My starting point: Indra, the Thunder God . Indra is a deity in Hindi and Buddhist texts, and he is often thought of as the Thunder God, God of the heavens, rains, lightning, and rivers flowing. He is known for defeating Vritra, a serpent monster associated with the drought, and he is seen in high regard. Also mentioned on his page is: Thor , the Norse God of Thunder. Thor is known for his red hair, beard, and his hammer that he wields. There is thought to be a parallel between Thor and Indra based on their hair color, and different weapons they wield that are considered to be signature items. Thor wields his hammer while Indra wields a thunderbolt named Vajra. Mentioned on Thor's page is: Thunder . This one should seem obvious, but an interesting thing about thunder is that while it is often considered to be connected to lightning in some way, it is a...

Week 10 Story: The Wise and Foolish Trader

The NASDAQ had already fallen 1200 basis points, the biggest crash in 10 years. Tech stocks fell further and further, with nothing but a sea of red on the historically upbeat ticker feed above the trading floor. Shouts from one trader to another rained out, but they were more out of desperation than information. The entire market was crashing, and no one could do anything about it. While many traders were winners and losers of this false-flag correction, two in particular stand out. A trader at Goldman and a trader at JP Morgan. Both accosted by a trader at Morgan Stanley, but only one escaping with his dignity- and more importantly, his money. One day, Salomon was sitting at his desk, and he noticed that NASDAQ and Dow futures were trading lower than normal. He ringed up one of his friends, Bill, at Goldman, and he mentioned how he was surprised that the market seemed to be going lower. Bill was also surprised. But the two were different in their reaction. Salomon was excited to s...

Week 6: Reading Notes, Mahabharata A

This week, we start reading a new Indian class, the Mahabharata, I chose to read the PDE (public domain edition) again, and this serves as notes for the first twenty stories within the epic. During the reading of the Ramayana, I would pre-read the plot on Wikipedia, this time, I will try to read only the PDE first, then the Wikipedia story if necessary. One thing that immediately stuck out was the high character turnover, compared to the Ramayana. In the Ramayana, there were not too many different characters, and the plot seemed to revolve around the characters. In contrast, the Mahabharata seems to have the characters revolve around a different plot. This seems to highlight the role that karma and the Gods play in the fate of the other people as their wills are shaped to the God's destiny. A second thing that stuck out was the role of curses in this story as well. In the ninth story of the PDE, "Pandu and His Wives", there is a similar role of a character killing som...